Why Barbie IS a Good Role Model!
Ruth Handler, the creator of Barbie, was initially inspired by her daughter’s playing habits. In the 1950s, the decade Barbie was created, the only dolls available were baby dolls. There were no dolls that filled an adult role. Realizing that there was huge potential in creating an adult doll that was not just a stay-at-home mom, Ruth Handler went on to create the Barbie that society knows today.
Over the years, Barbie has been subject to all kinds of controversy, mainly because of her “unrealistic” body type that critics claim can hurt the self esteem of young girls and influence them in a negative way. However, these critics are ONLY basing their criticism on Barbie’s looks, which ironically, is something that we are taught not to do. “Don’t judge a book by its cover,” is a common saying, yet critics of Barbie are doing just that. They totally disregard everything that Barbie stands for, focusing strictly on her plastic NOT REAL body.
The first thing that I would like to address is that Barbie is not the source of body issues. In fact, body stereotypes are what created Barbie in the first place. As can be seen in these fashion ads from the 1950s, Barbie was designed after the body images that already existed: trim waist, long legs, etc. Don’t blame Barbie for causing self esteem issues; she merely reflects what is popular and idealized in society. She did not cause the problem in the first place.
Before Barbie, there had never been an adult doll with a career. When the first doll given to girls is a baby doll, what message does that send? Barbie broke the glass ceiling and became the ultimate career woman. She has had over 150 careers throughout the years. Pretty much anything you can think of, Barbie has been it. This not only includes stereotypical “feminine” jobs.
She was an astronaut in the 1960s, when she went to the moon four years before Neil Armstrong. She was already a CEO in the 1980s, just as women were starting to gain leverage in the workplace. Not to mention that she has already been president a couple times, and America has yet to have a female candidate on the ballot.
Barbie shows young girls that they really can be anything that they want to be. In the 1980s and 1990s, Mattel’s slogan was, “We girls can do anything, right Barbie?” Many readers may be familiar with the Barbie “I Can Be” campaign, showing girls that anything is possible. Barbie is the ultimate feminist, and no doubt she has had a role in empowering women around the world.
Many people also criticize Barbie’s dream lifestyle, filled with the color pink, clothes, shoes, and convertibles. Honestly, what is wrong with living the Barbie lifestyle? It is perfectly okay to strive to be successful, feminine, and fabulous. Where do you think Barbie got all the money for that stuff? From her successful career, obviously!
Barbie never lets men control her life. Many people forget that the Ken doll was made to compliment the Barbie doll, not the other way around. Ken has never held Barbie back in her career. In fact, he often fades into the background, letting Barbie be the center of attention, something that radical feminists are striving for. They want to be recognized for their accomplishments and their work alone, and that is exactly what Barbie does.
No matter how many positives I explain about Barbie, the argument will always circle back to her body shape. It is important to remember that Barbie was NEVER created to be anatomically correct. She cannot be some chunky doll, she has to be easy to maneuver and dress quickly. Her figure has to be smaller and leaner to look normal in the clothes.
Justina Sharp, fashion blogger, puts it perfectly, “I’ve heard the main argument against her before: that she’s too perfect, with her tiny waist and itty-bitty feet, and she’s bad for little girls’ self-esteem. But this is not how little girls see Barbie; rather this is how adults with issues of their own perceive Barbie. I played with Barbies as a little girl (I’ll admit it,still play with Barbies), and guess what? I have never wanted to look like her. Still don’t. She’s beautiful, but she’s a plastic doll. Any 5-year-old can see that. Barbie’s got a charmed life, but it’s not a real one. Adult issues should not be put upon a toy or a little girl.”
There is nothing wrong with Barbie’s slim physique. Childhood obesity rates have skyrocketed in the United States. Barbie helps contradict that. Not only is she healthy looking, but she is always on the move. She is never sitting around on the couch watching television; she is always out doing some sort of activity, something which a lot of couch potatoes would benefit from. There is nothing wrong with striving to be healthier and a better version of yourself.
Finally, it is important to remember that Barbie is nothing more than a toy. Feminists and other critics constantly blame her for the woes of the world, self-esteem issues, and the view of the female body in general. Now, that is fine, but honestly, it is pretty pathetic. There is SO much more that goes into a girl’s worldview than toys. Her parents, friends, TV shows, magazines, media, and society in general play a much bigger role than toys in her world view. Barbie’s body is only a mirror of what society perceives as “the perfect woman”. People need to step back and take a look at the bigger picture here, and stop blaming a toy for the low self esteem epidemic.
Through the years, Barbie has accepted the criticisms thrown at her, and continued to be her own successful person, something that I think many women can learn from in today’s world.
Alexa Janczewski • Apr 15, 2015 at 10:33 pm
I agree with Claire. Barbie is a great role model for young girls all around the world. The main slogan behind Barbie is ” I Can Be”, the meaning behind this saying is: young girls can be anything they want to be. In Barbie’s case, she had many jobs and careers. She even had careers that were unique and motivating such as an astronaut. I agree with the saying that young children are taught not to judge a book by its cover. This is why I believe that the controversy behind Barbie’s figure is wrong. I think that if anything Barbie is motivation for young girls in both physical and mental ways. Physically young girls see how beautiful and fit Barbie is and this can motivate them to live a healthy life style. Mentally Barbie shows young girls that becoming successful and following your dreams is right. Barbie was my role model growing up. She continues to be one proving that you can be anything you want to be. Claire, your article was written really well and you shared a lot of factual and credible points. Your writing style is clean and easy to follow. Great topic Choice!
Mattie Kon • Apr 15, 2015 at 8:12 am
Dear Editor, you makes all the incredible arguments that back up Barbie and I agree completely with this article. Barbie is usually viewed as this skinny doll that lowers girls self esteem but nobody ever talks about what a great role model she is in the careers perspective. Barbie was made to motivate girls and their view on what they can do in the world and Barbie has have over 150 jobs to do this. She has been president, an astronaut, vet, and a fire fighter. Most of these jobs have also been mostly men too and Barbie breaks those standards. Barbie was never made to tell girls to look like her, she was made to tell girls she can be anything. Also, most of the age group who even plays with Barbies aren’t really in the age where girls get self conscience. The people who talk negatively about Barbie are adults who are blaming there own personal issues as a doll. I believe that Barbie is the least of our worries when it comes to self consciences. The biggest factors are models, movies,and magazines, not s doll we played with as a child. Overall, Claire did an amazing job stating the same points I did and her article did a great job teaching me more about the argument I already agreed with.
Emma ellis • Apr 15, 2015 at 7:52 am
I, being someone who has fallen into the Barbie hating fad, found this article very eye opening. Barbie is a product of society. It is easy to blame “society” as though it is this unknown evil when in fact we are all contributors. I feel as though people are always extremely eager to blindly join other in hatred. If you really look at Barbie, despite her body, she stands for something beautiful. Plus she is a doll, have you ever seen a doll that accurately resembled a human being? Barbie truly is the ultimate feminist and shows young children a woman in many different professional roles. In order to move forward with feminism the new generation needs to have it instilled in them from a young age.
Catie Murphy • Apr 14, 2015 at 11:13 am
I completely agree Claire and with everyone else who has commented! I do not understand why it matters that Barbie is such a beautiful young woman yet she has career goals. Are we all only allowed to be defined as one thing, Barbie herself being beauty? Does this mean Barbie is not allowed to be a doctor or an astronaut because she is attractive? She is a great role model for all girls.
Brittany Hoffman • Apr 13, 2015 at 2:05 pm
Dear Editor,
You make several great points about the criticism that the Barbie doll gets. These dolls show a variety of ways women can be seen as whether it be the stay at home mom, CEO, amd even president. Young women today let other people chose their careers for them or the men make the money, the Barbie doll is a creative way to end those paths early on. One controversy involving such femine dolls are body stereotypes; however, now that you mention it stereotypes did “create” the doll not the other way around. Little girls can be what ever they want and have the figure they want. They dont need a man to tell them their beautiful or that they can delend on them. I actually didnt know that the Ken doll was made to compliment Barbie, but that just shows that Barbie shows that Independance is key. All in all, your argument is, in my eyes, completly valid and those who criticize your opinion are being slightly close minded.
Claire Radler • Apr 14, 2015 at 11:14 am
Thanks for your comment and support Brittany! I really worked hard on this article and I’m glad you agree/appreciate it!
Erina Loupos • Apr 14, 2015 at 11:16 am
I agree with you! Barbie is a great role model for girls- she is able to be herself (a girly girl) while still having the career of her dreams, even the president! Having Barbie in the spotlight instead of Ken further shows how independent she is. I think there is nothing wrong with looking up to Barbie as a role model.
Christi Lato • Apr 13, 2015 at 2:02 pm
Dear editor,
I really enjoyed reading this article. Not only because I love Barbies, but also because you brought up really good points that others do not really think about. You started off the articles strong with good background information of the creator of babrbie and the point of Barbie. A great sentence that really stuck to me was, “However, these critics are ONLY basing their criticism off Barbies looks, which ironically is something we are taught not to do.” (Radler 2). Everyone always complains about Barbie because she is ‘unrealistic’ or ‘perfect’. I like how you pointed out that this is the opinion of the adults, not the children. The children are the ones playing with the toys and not the adults so why should they let it bug them. I’m sure all kids playing with Barbies do not even think about her body because they are too young to even know that. All the kids are gonna know is how awesome Barbie is. When I was little, Barbie was my dream not because of how she looked but because she was able to do everything. She was like superwoman. Critics need to get past the looks of her, which were necessary for to change outfits all the time, and realize that she is a good thing for young girls to think of. It made me think that I can be anything I wanted to be when I was older. I agree with you when you say that there’s a “bigger picture here, and stop blaming a toy for the low self esteem epidemic.”(12). Yes obesity is an issue in America and we cannot just shove it off and blames other reasons. So even if they want to ‘look like Barbie’ at al, it is good motivation to want to be healthy. I’m sure that if there was a fat Barbie doll, critics would tear that down too and that would say it’s okay to be obese. That is not okay. The haters are always gonna hate. So we just need to “be who you wanna be B-A-R-B-I-E”. (That’s a reference to the song of the Barbie commercial). Good job editor, you wrote well and made really good points. Thank you!
Claire Radler • Apr 14, 2015 at 11:13 am
Thanks for your comment Christi! I like the reference to the Barbie commercial song, that was a nice touch.
Annie Moore • Apr 13, 2015 at 1:48 pm
I think that this article was extremely interesting. I have never seen this dispute from this side before. I agree that Barbie is more empowering than harmful to young girls. You make a great point when you looked at it from the career perspective. Barbie does encourage girls to be ambitious as well as to be themselves. Despite Barbie’s ever changing careers, she is always the same girly Barbie. She doesn’t let a career define her, she defines her. I also liked how you brought up her male counter point. It’s important to remember that Barbie is the center of attention, not her boyfriend. After reading your article I definitely have a different attitude about the whole Barbie dispute. If people wanted Barbie to look more realistic, there would have to be a change in the way magazines and social media portray women first. Barbie is not who to blame here, we are. Good job Claire!
Claire Radler • Apr 14, 2015 at 11:12 am
Thanks for your comment Annie! I also strongly agree with you when you say, “If people wanted Barbie to look more realistic, there would have to be a change in the way magazines and social media portray women first. Barbie is not who to blame here, we are.” That’s exactly the point I was trying to get across!